The henley shirt is a must-have staple for every man’s closet. The simple long sleeve goes a long way no matter what weather or outfit, but how are you supposed to know which henley is best for your needs? If you want a soft feel, is it better to find a shirt that’s 100% cotton or a cotton blend? Which brands are true to size, and which ones will you need to size up in? And furthermore, where are the best places to shop for the perfect henley? At this point, it seems like every menswear brand has a version of the henley, and each claims their own as the best.
It can be pretty overwhelming, with brands offering a multitude of fabrics, fits, and styles. Plus, there’s the added difficulty of finding the right brand that aligns with your needs and values. Luckily, we’ve already done all the research for you. With each shirt, we’ve compiled information about its fit and material, as well as details about the brand itself.
Here is a list of the Best Henleys for Men:
The Best Henleys: Our Picks
Banana Republic
Banana Republic is a modern clothing company that emphasizes timeless pieces fit for any occasion. The brand was initially known for business casual pieces, but now produce a wide variety of clothing for women and men. The company is incredibly sustainable and sells clothes around the globe.
Banana Republic’s Indigo Henley T-shirt comes in a standard fit, so you should stay true to size when purchasing this item. The shirt comes with the option of Regular length, or you can choose from Banana Republic’s Tall line. This henley has full-length sleeves and four buttons down the center, so you can opt for a looser collar. It’s 100% cotton and incredibly soft to the touch. It’s not too thin or too thick. As the name suggests, the shirt is a rich indigo color, and comes in sizes XS-XXL.
Amazon Goodthreads
Amazon is a global company that sells almost any item a customer could be looking for. Amazon is a platform for other clothing retailers to sell their garments, and the brand also has their own line. Amazon’s Goodthreads Long-Sleeve Lightweight Slub Henley comes in a standard fit that is a bit on the slimmer side. If you prefer a looser look, it’s recommended that you size up.
It comes with three buttons down the front, long sleeves, and a slightly rounded hem for a tasteful look. The shirt is 100% cotton and imported, made with lightweight jersey slub cotton. This means it has a unique texture with some subtle, irregular twists in the fabric. This gives it a soft feel and is quite comfortable. The shirt comes in 10 colors, from neutrals to bright hues, and the sizes range from XS-3X.
Carhartt
Carhartt is a brand that produces top-tier workwear for many kinds of activities. They are known for hardy, long-lasting items that are tailored for the working individual. Carhartt’s Loose Fit heavyweight Long-sleeve Pocket Henley T-shirt provides a more oversized look and feel.
One advantage of buying from Carhartt is that they lay out the different fits of their clothing items, such as the difference between loose fit and relaxed fit. The shirt has three buttons down the front with a standard henley collar. The solid colors are made with 100% cotton, and the heathers with different ratios of a cotton and polyester blend. The 100% cotton shirts will be softer than the blends, and the shirt is designed to be heavier. This will provide you with more warmth and structure. The shirt comes in nine colors and the sizes range from S-4X.
American Eagle
American Eagle is a popular, trendy clothing brand that produces casual wear for many occasions. The brand sells globally and has lines for women and men. American Eagle’s Super Soft Henley T-shirt provides a great short sleeve option to the list. The shirt comes in a standard fit and length, so it’s recommended to stay true to size when purchasing.
The hem is curved, giving it a unique look on the wearer, and the shirt has three small buttons coming down the front. The short sleeves are cuffed. It’s made with 100% cotton and is incredibly soft to the touch. It’s very lightweight, which contributes to its soft feel. The shirt comes in oatmeal, which is a very versatile color.
Wahts
Wahts is a high-quality menswear brand that creates everyday, modern clothing items. The company produces clothing, footwear, and accessories, and their clothes range from more luxury items to sportswear. Wahts’ Cruz Piqué Henley Shirt is made with a tailored fit, giving a slimmer and more fitted feel. It comes with long sleeves and cuffs on the wrist for a more secure feel on the arms.
The shirt has four mother-of-pearl buttons in the center, which come down a bit longer than other shirts. It is made with 100% Piqué cotton, which is a luxury fabric that has a quilted texture. This material is commonly used for high-quality sportswear to keep the wearer cool during movement. The shirt comes in three muted colors, and the sizes range from XS-3X.
Pistol Lake
Pistol Lake is a relatively new menswear brand that creates practical yet stylish clothes. The brand emphasizes the need for ethical, aesthetic clothing designed for the outdoors. Pistol Lake’s Cotton Henley has a bit of a looser fit, but still fits comfortably. The shirt has three buttons down the front and cuffs on its long sleeves.
The shoulders are created to ensure maximum movement. It’s made of 100% organic cotton and lightweight material, which makes it great for layering. The fabric is soft, but tightly knit to ensure comfort. It’s been pre-shrunk and stays soft without changing shape after many washes. The shirt has many color options: there are six basic colors to choose from, as well as a range of limited colors. The sizes range from XS-XXL.